# Leaving a Brokerage, Bank or Insurance Advisor

Source: https://integrityfinancialplan.com/leaving-a-brokerage-or-bank-advisor
Last updated: 2026-11-16

Thinking of leaving your brokerage, bank or insurance advisor for an independent, fee-only fiduciary? See what changes, what to review and how a move works.


If you have already decided you want an independent, fee-only fiduciary, the next questions are practical: what changes, what you should review first and how your accounts would move. Todd Smurl, CFA, walks you through each step before anything is transferred.

## Key takeaways

- Start with what you actually pay and what you own, not a firm's maximum fee schedule. A fee-only adviser is not automatically less expensive.
- Eligible holdings can often transfer in kind without a sale. Account type, nontransferable holdings, annuity surrender charges and taxes need separate review.
- Our advisory fee is 1.0% per year on the first $1 million, 0.85% from $1 million to $10 million, and negotiable above $10 million. Financial planning is included as part of the investment management fee. For clients with assets under management under $500,000, the Advisor reserves the right to charge an hourly fee for financial planning.

## Who this is for

- Retirees and people planning for retirement who work with an advisor at a brokerage firm, bank or insurance company
- Households who want one person responsible for both their portfolio and their personal financial plan
- Investors who want to understand their current costs, holdings and tax position before deciding to move

## Problems it solves

- Not knowing what you actually pay in advisory fees, fund expenses and other charges
- Uncertainty about whether your advisor acts as a broker, an investment adviser or both
- Concern that moving accounts will mean selling everything and triggering taxes

## What makes it different

Integrity Financial Planning is independent and fee-only: we are paid only by our clients, sell no products and accept no commissions. Our fees are published, and Todd Smurl, CFA, manages your portfolio and your plan himself.

## Why investors make the switch

Advisors at brokerage firms, banks and insurance companies can be paid in ways that depend on what you buy. The SEC's Regulation Best Interest requires broker-dealers to disclose conflicts of interest, including those tied to proprietary products, payments from third parties and compensation arrangements ([SEC](https://sec.gov/resources-small-businesses/small-business-compliance-guides/regulation-best-interest)). Disclosure does not remove the incentive; it tells you it exists.

Costs matter too. The SEC notes that fees which seem small can have a major impact on a portfolio over time ([SEC Investor Bulletin](https://www.sec.gov/oiea/investor-alerts-bulletins/ib-fees-expenses)). A 2015 White House Council of Economic Advisers review estimated that conflicted advice can reduce IRA savers' returns by roughly 1 percentage point a year, while noting the estimate is uncertain ([Council of Economic Advisers](https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/docs/cea_coi_report_final.pdf)). Your own situation depends on your accounts, holdings and the advice you receive.

Integrity Financial Planning is independent and fee-only. We are paid only by our clients, sell no products and accept no commissions. Fee-only does not mean an adviser has no conflicts, so ask every adviser, including us, to explain the conflicts described in their [Form ADV](https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/310974).

## What changes and what doesn't

| | What changes | What can stay the same |
|---|---|---|
| Who advises you | Todd Smurl, CFA, manages your portfolio and personal financial plan | You keep control; accounts remain in your name |
| How the adviser is paid | Client fees only, published on our [fees page](/fees) | Your existing account types, such as IRAs and taxable accounts |
| Where assets are held | Altruist becomes the custodian | Eligible holdings can often transfer in kind, without a sale |
| Your plan | Retirement income, Social Security, RMDs, taxes and estate coordination in one plan | Your existing CPA and attorney, with whom we coordinate |

## Five steps to switching

1. **Introductory meeting.** A free, no-obligation conversation with Todd about your goals, your current advice and what you want to change.
2. **Review what you have.** We go through your statements, fee agreement, holdings, cost basis and any annuity or insurance contracts. You see what you pay in dollars, not just percentages.
3. **Agree on the route.** We identify which assets can move in kind, which need separate handling and the potential tax effects of each choice before you authorize anything.
4. **Authorize the transfer.** Eligible brokerage assets typically move through ACATS; IRAs, employer plans and other assets may need different instructions. [FINRA Rule 11870](https://www.finra.org/rules-guidance/rulebooks/finra-rules/11870) describes the procedures and exceptions. Timing depends on your accounts and is not guaranteed.
5. **Build your portfolio and plan.** After assets arrive, we review the holdings and agree on any changes, considering taxes and the risks of selling or keeping each position. Your [Personal Index Portfolio](/services/personal-index-portfolios) and [financial plan](/services/financial-planning) are built around your goals.

## Questions to ask your current advisor first

- What is my total annual cost, in dollars, including advisory, manager, platform and fund expenses?
- Is my account a brokerage account, an advisory account or both?
- Do you or your firm earn anything from the funds, annuities or products I own?
- Are any of my holdings proprietary or unable to transfer to another firm?
- Is my cash included in the fee, and what rate does it earn compared with a money market fund? In January 2025 the [SEC said](https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2025-16) the yield gap between some firms' bank sweep programs and other cash options at times grew to almost 4%.
- Are you acting as a fiduciary on every one of my accounts, all the time, or only when you make certain recommendations?
- Does your firm receive revenue sharing or other payments from the funds or managers in my accounts?
- Would any surrender, transfer or termination charges apply if I moved?

If an answer is vague, that is useful information too. Not sure where to find these numbers? [Request a free fee review](/fee-review): share a recent statement and fee agreement, and Todd will prepare a written estimate of what you pay now, with no obligation and no promise of savings. For a deeper comparison of costs and transfer details, read [Leaving a large brokerage firm? What to know before you move](/insights/leaving-a-wirehouse-for-a-fee-only-fiduciary).

## Why Integrity Financial Planning

- **Independent, fee-only fiduciary.** Paid only by clients, with no commissions or product incentives. We are members of the [Institute for the Fiduciary Standard](https://thefiduciaryinstitute.org/real-fiduciary-advisors/).
- **Published, transparent fees.** See our [fee schedule](/fees). Optional Altruist active tax management costs up to 0.10% a year on enrolled taxable assets, separate from our advisory fee.
- **Customized tax management.** Personal Index Portfolios hold individual stocks in place of a large-cap fund, which allows [tax-loss harvesting](/insights/introduction-to-tax-loss-harvesting) in taxable accounts and a tax-aware transition from the holdings you already own.
- **Values-based investing, if you want it.** Client-directed exclusions for [faith-based or ESG preferences](/who-we-serve/values-based-investors).
- **One-on-one with Todd.** [Todd Smurl, CFA](/about/todd-smurl), founded the firm after 30 years in financial services, including roles at Goldman Sachs Personal Financial Management, Compass Bank and Bank of America's Private Bank. Prior employment does not imply those firms endorse Integrity Financial Planning.

We work with [retirees and people planning for retirement](/who-we-serve/retirees-and-pre-retirees) in [Houston](/financial-advisor-houston) and by video.

## Talk with Todd

[Schedule a free, no-obligation introductory meeting with Todd](/schedule) to discuss your current advice, what you pay and whether a move makes sense for you. Want the numbers first? [Request a free fee review](/fee-review). Prefer to ask a question first? [Contact us](/contact).

This page is educational and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. A transfer can involve charges, restrictions or tax consequences. Fees, returns and tax results vary and are not guaranteed. See our [published fees](/fees) and Form ADV Part 2A for full terms.

## Frequently asked questions

### How do I switch from a brokerage or bank advisor to a fee-only fiduciary?

Start with a review of your current statements, fee agreement and holdings. Then agree on which assets can move in kind, which need separate handling and what the tax effects could be. After you authorize the transfer, the receiving custodian requests the eligible assets. Integrity Financial Planning uses Altruist as custodian; we explain each step before you sign anything.

### Will I owe taxes if I move my accounts?

An in-kind transfer of eligible taxable holdings is generally not a sale, but it is not a blanket tax-free promise. A sale, an account-type change, a retirement-plan distribution or a Roth conversion can have different consequences. We review the route, cost basis and any nontransferable holdings before recommending a move. See the [IRS explanation of transfers and rollovers](https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/rollovers-of-retirement-plan-and-ira-distributions).

### Do I have to tell my current advisor I am leaving?

For an eligible ACATS transfer, the receiving firm can start the request after you authorize it, so a separate conversation is generally not required. Some assets, contracts or services need separate instructions, and some people choose to speak with their current advisor first.

### What about annuities or insurance products I already own?

We do not sell insurance or annuities, but we can review the coverage and contracts you already own as part of your plan. Surrender charges, guarantees, riders and tax treatment differ by contract, so keeping, exchanging or holding a contract is a separate decision made on its own facts.

### How much does Integrity Financial Planning charge?

Our advisory fee is 1.0% per year on the first $1 million, 0.85% from $1 million to $10 million, and negotiable above $10 million. Financial planning is included as part of the investment management fee. For clients with assets under management under $500,000, the Advisor reserves the right to charge an hourly fee for financial planning. Optional Altruist active tax management costs up to 0.10% a year on enrolled taxable assets, separate from our fee; we receive none of it. See [our fees](/fees).

### Can I work with you if I don't live in Houston?

Meetings can be held by video or phone. Integrity Financial Planning is registered in Texas and Louisiana; we confirm whether we can work with you in your state before you become a client.
